Hobbes and Plato

Hobbes and Plato Hobbes and Plato both constructed images of an ideal state, based on their accounts of human nature. Hobbes had a more negatively skewed view of human nature; a materialistic view, while Plato essentially believed that humans are inherently good. This essay will discuss how their differing views are conveyed in their imagined states, and subsequently will critically compare the two. Thomas Hobbes had a materialistic philosophy; he held a mechanistic view of the universe. In his opinion, human nature is the the combined result of mechanic desires and aversions, arbitrated by constant power struggles.He posited that there is no true right and wrong but that morality is subjectively relative, â€Å"He states that there is no good but the object of a mans desire, no evil but an object of aversion, and that there is no absolute right or wrong, but merely a relative morality that favors the reason of the user† ( Tyluski, associatedcontent.com). In Hobbes view, mans natural condition or state of nature is innately violent and aggressive, saturated with fear. He illustrates his belief with the hypothetical image of the natural state of mankind, prior to a government ruling society, as one of constant war, aggression, fear and death. He proposed that since resources are limited, as soon as two people want the same thing, a power struggle results and inevitably war erupts. If men were to live in this state of nature then all lives would be â€Å"solitary, poore, nasty, brutish, and short.( Hobbes, pg.186). Based on this diabolical image, Hobbes contends that the best solution to this state of nature is his Leviathan. He argues that in order for mankind to exist and live in peace and harmony, they must first submit to a sovereign power. Hobbes truly believed that control by an oppressive government was infinitely better than living under the threat of war. In order to alleviate the constant fear, mankind must enter into a social contract in a commonwealth ruled over by a sovereign head. Thus the Leviathan is formed in order to overcome the fear based lives of men in the state of nature. However, ironically the Leviathan is only possible if it uses fear itself as a weapon. Therefore fear is never completely dismissed. However fear under the Leviathan at least brings the promise of peace and protection of life, in contrast to fear in the state of nature. Following from this, the Leviathan seems immensely more desirable a condition to live in. It appears that it is only under a sovereign p ower that people have actual liberty. Certainly there are rules and regulations to live by, but as the subjects actually wrote the social contract they find themselves under, they are indeed authors of the sovereigns power. It seems that freedom can only really exist under a soverieign power permitted by its people, â€Å"establish a Leviathan whose power is assigned to it by its subjects† (Tyluski, associatedcontent.com). In Platos Republic, Glaucon and Adeimantus have entreated Socrates to explain that the best life a man can live is a just one, and that it will ultimately lead to happiness. Socrates must show that justice should be chosen for its own merit and not for the results that derive from it. Since a city is larger than a man, it is easier for Socrates to first look for justice at a political level within a state, and following from that to see whether the virtues found can be transferred to an individual. â€Å"Morality might exist on a larger scale in the larger entity and be easier to discernAnd then we can examine individuals too, to see if the larger entity is reflected in the features of the smaller entity† ( Plato, pg 58). Therefore the collective justice found within a state will be reflected in the justice of an individual. Plato saw justice not as a set of behaviours, but rather as a structural entity. The structure of a city holds political justice while in an individual ju stice can be found in the structure of the soul. Plato explains that in his ideal state there must exist the four virtues of wisdom, courage, moderation and justice. His imagined state will be divided into three classes of people; producers, auxilaries and guardians. The producers are the lowest class, such as farmers, artisans, and craftsmen. They must use the skills which nature honoured them with. Auxilaries are the warrior class who must defend the rulers beliefs and doctrines. The guardians are the highest class and they are the rulers of this imagined state. When the balance and relationship between these three classes is correct then this is a just society. Plato then takes his image of a perfect state and starts searching for each of the previously mentioned virtues. He begins by discovering that wisdom resides in the class of the guardians. They are the smallest class in the city. The guardians have had the best education, and have been finely honed for this role. They have a thorough knowledge of running a city. They are rational and desire what is in the best interest for the city as a whole. Therefore with the city in their hands, it is made wise, â€Å"the wisdom it has a whole is due to the smallest grouping and section within it and to the knowledge possessed by this group, which is the authoritative and ruling section of the community† ( Plato, pg. 135). The next virtue Plato comes across is courage and this is found in the auxilaries. The auxilaries must fight for the city and defend the wishes of the guardians. More specifically, the type of courage which is found in the auxilaries is civic courage. That is to say, it is a type of courage which is based on belief rather than knowledge. He defines courage in this instance as, â€Å"the ability to retain under all circumstances a true and lawful notion about what is and is not to be feared† (Plato, pg. 137). Plato places great importance on the significance of education and thorough training.He emphasises how imperative standing by the specific role of performing with courage as an auxilary is, regardless of the pressures which arise â€Å"keeping it intact and not losing it whether one is under the influence of pain or pleasue, diversion or aversion.† (Plato, pg. 136). Moderation is the thrid virtue, and is found throughout the state, â€Å" self-discipline(moderation) literally spans the whole octaval spread of the community, and makes the weakest, the strongest, and the ones in between all sing in unison†( Plato, pg. 139). While courage and wisdom are essential qualities which are found in only specific parts of the community, moderation is a virtue which reconciles and brings together all the parts of the city. Moderation comes about by the acceptance that all are in agreement concerning who should rule the city. It is found in all classes, and is attained by a common understanding of what is best for all people. With regard to justice in the state, again it is found throughout the state. Justice complements moderation in the city. Plato deems that â€Å"morality(justice) is doing ones own job and not intruding elsewhere† (Plato, pg. 140). Plato believes that justice best comes about when everyone attends to the role that they are most suited to. As a just society is made up of three classes, similarly a just soul parallels it and is tripartite in its structure; the rational, the spirited and the appetitive. A just soul constantly attempts to achieve and live completely in truth. Therefore the rational part of the soul rules, and the spirited part supports the rational, with the appetitive part submitting and following reason. That is to say the whole soul is geared towards satisfying the desires of the rational, just as in the imagined state everyone fulfills the rulers desires. Within the society, each class is dominated by the corresponding part of the soul. Producers are ruled by their appetites; their urges for money, material things and pleasure. Warriors are ruled by their spirits; they are brave and courageous. Rulers are influenced by their rationale. Therefore justice in a soul as in the state, relies on the the appropriate power relationship between each part, â€Å"Morality, then is an inner state.It is harmony b etween the parts of a persons mind under the leadership of his or her intellect† ( Plato, pg. 152). In this way Platos account of human nature directly informs his theory of an ideal state. Platos Republic and Hobbes Leviathan both share the common understanding that without a state or governing body in place, all mankind would disintegrate into a state of chaos; with desires, appetites and aversions being the dominant cause behind behaviour. They reflect each other in that both believe submission to and acceptance of a ruling body will result in harmony. However beyond this similarity, the views of these philosophers greatly differ. The Republic is based on a quest for justice in both the state and individual; in Platos view people are inherently good. Plato constructs his ideal state,and then searches for virtues within it, which will also be present in the tripartite soul of individuals. By this method, he shows that in a just state or soul, these virtues must be present and each class or reciprocal part of soul must have the correct balance of power. In this way harmony is attained. Although men may commit some terrible acts, this is due to their appetitive desires rather than an innate negative drive. Although Hobbes also believes that men are dominantly driven by their desires and aversions, he does not think that men are ultimately driven to do good but rather by what will give them power and will ultimately protect them. Hobbes builds his state on a foundation of fear of war and terror. He does not consider that what is correct and just is found naturally in humans, â€Å"The notions of right and wrong, justice and injustice have there no place† ( Hobbes, pg. 188). He does not look for virtues in men but instead only seeks , â€Å"those qualities of man-kind that concern their living together in Peace, and Unity.†( Hobbes, pg. 160). Hobbes does not believe there exists a state of happiness in the soul, that it is a state that is a constant, that can be held on to, â€Å"Felicity is a continuall progresse of the desire, from one object to another† (Hobbes,pg. 160). Plato builds his state on the principle of specialization, â€Å"At the center of his model is a principle of specialization: each person should perform just the task to which he is best suited.† (Brown, SEP). Every man has a place, and does the job for which he is deemed most fit for. In this way all jobs in the state are done to the highest standard, and the needs of the state are met adequately, resulting in a healthy state. This ensures each class remains in a fixed state of power and influence. In contrast, Hobbes does not see men as being any different from each other, rather he believes that we are all completely equal, â€Å"Nature hath make man so equal in the faculties of body and mind; as that though there be found one man sometimes manifestly stronger in body, or of quicker mind than another; yet when all is reckoned together, the difference between man and man is not so considerable† (Hobbes, pg. 183). Plato believes that there exists an elite few that poss ess a greater knowledge and absolute truth. It is these few who convey the moralistic way of life to the rest of society. Converesly, Hobbes does not think that there is any one who is in possession of truth, and does not see the state as responsible for moral reasoning within society. Rather the only role the government plays in his eyes is a lawful one, a peace keeping role to avoid the harm one man may cause another. While Platos state is often referred to as an unattainable Utopia, it is still a model which can be aspired to, as an existence with order, meaning and harmony, both within the individual and on a larger scale. Hobbes Leviathan contrarily, is built out of fear and chaos, rather than being something to aspire to, it seems to be more something that is settled for, when there is no other alternative. Bibliography: Brown, E., 2009, Platos Ethics and Politics in the Republic, , 03/04/10. Hobbes, T., 1968, Leviathan( Pelican Classics), London, Penguin. Plato, 1993, Republic: translated by Robin Waterfield, Oxford, Oxford University Press. Tyluski, M., 2009, Human Nature in Hobbes Leviathan, , 03/04/10.

Being Covered from the Truth in Araby by James Joyce Essay -- Araby ja

Being Covered from the Truth in Araby by James Joyce â€Å"Araby† by James Joyce, is a short story about a young boy trying to find and his search for inner happiness. The main setting takes place in the boy’s neighborhood where he lives with his aunt and uncle. The sub setting takes place in an Araby or English bazaar, a carnival if you will. In the neighborhood we find that there is; an uninhabited house that has not been occupied for some time, a girl, who’s referred to as ‘Mangan’s sister’, whom the boy has a lustful crush on, and a story of a deceased priest. In the Araby we find a lot of empty booths, along with some hollow characters. The neighborhood, the Araby, the boy, and other characters in the story have an overall theme of being covered from the truth. The neighborhood has many examples of people and objects that are covered from the truth. The first object described in the story is that of an empty house that stood at the end of the street. The street was blind, a dead end, and the house was â€Å"detached from its neighbors†¦Ã¢â‚¬  (para.1). The fact that it was detached from all the other houses gives the impression that it was hiding from the other houses or that it was covering itself from the truth. â€Å"The other houses on the street† were â€Å"conscious of decent lives within them,† (para. 1) while the lone spacious house was hid from all decent life. The true purpose of a house is for the habitation of humans, so if a house is not doing that, then in a sense it is hiding itself from the truth of its creation, and from the other houses that are living up to their creation. This pattern of ‘covering’ or ‘hiding’ is continued in the third paragraph, by the explanation of how the boy and his friends ... ...he men accused the girl of saying something to which she denied trying to cover information or the truth from her accusers. The conversation starts with the girl’s denial: â€Å"Oh I never said such a thing!† â€Å"O, but you did!† â€Å"O, but I didn’t!† â€Å"Did she say that?† â€Å"Yes, I heard her.† â€Å"O, there’s a †¦ fib!† (Para. 27-32) The sub setting of the Araby and it’s characters are shown to be covered from the truth, for an Araby should be a fun and entertaining place, while it’s workers should be energetic and enthusiastic, which neither lived up to it’s truth. The main setting of the neighborhood with the uninhabited house, the boy, Mangan’s sister, and the priest, gives many examples of characters in hiding. As well as the Araby with its empty carnival and dull workers, all support the idea or theme of being covered from the truth. Being Covered from the Truth in Araby by James Joyce Essay -- Araby ja Being Covered from the Truth in Araby by James Joyce â€Å"Araby† by James Joyce, is a short story about a young boy trying to find and his search for inner happiness. The main setting takes place in the boy’s neighborhood where he lives with his aunt and uncle. The sub setting takes place in an Araby or English bazaar, a carnival if you will. In the neighborhood we find that there is; an uninhabited house that has not been occupied for some time, a girl, who’s referred to as ‘Mangan’s sister’, whom the boy has a lustful crush on, and a story of a deceased priest. In the Araby we find a lot of empty booths, along with some hollow characters. The neighborhood, the Araby, the boy, and other characters in the story have an overall theme of being covered from the truth. The neighborhood has many examples of people and objects that are covered from the truth. The first object described in the story is that of an empty house that stood at the end of the street. The street was blind, a dead end, and the house was â€Å"detached from its neighbors†¦Ã¢â‚¬  (para.1). The fact that it was detached from all the other houses gives the impression that it was hiding from the other houses or that it was covering itself from the truth. â€Å"The other houses on the street† were â€Å"conscious of decent lives within them,† (para. 1) while the lone spacious house was hid from all decent life. The true purpose of a house is for the habitation of humans, so if a house is not doing that, then in a sense it is hiding itself from the truth of its creation, and from the other houses that are living up to their creation. This pattern of ‘covering’ or ‘hiding’ is continued in the third paragraph, by the explanation of how the boy and his friends ... ...he men accused the girl of saying something to which she denied trying to cover information or the truth from her accusers. The conversation starts with the girl’s denial: â€Å"Oh I never said such a thing!† â€Å"O, but you did!† â€Å"O, but I didn’t!† â€Å"Did she say that?† â€Å"Yes, I heard her.† â€Å"O, there’s a †¦ fib!† (Para. 27-32) The sub setting of the Araby and it’s characters are shown to be covered from the truth, for an Araby should be a fun and entertaining place, while it’s workers should be energetic and enthusiastic, which neither lived up to it’s truth. The main setting of the neighborhood with the uninhabited house, the boy, Mangan’s sister, and the priest, gives many examples of characters in hiding. As well as the Araby with its empty carnival and dull workers, all support the idea or theme of being covered from the truth.

Accident Rates

More than 60 per cent of road accidents that occur between 10 p. M. And 6 a. M. Are because of drunken driving. A death occurs every 4 minutes on Indian Roads. According to Decca Chronicle, Karakas ranks 3rd in the list of Top 5 states with highest road accidents. More than 60% of road accidents occur because of drunken driving. Decca Chronicle – Karakas ranks 3rd- Top states with highest roads accidents Good afternoon ladies and gentlemen, You as you know are traffic policemen (and women) and we are your senior police officials.Today we are here to discuss an issue of grave importance to each one of us – A new Promotion Policy. Here is an eye opener for the entire Bangers traffic police force. And we hope this sensitizes each one of us to the bigger picture. A death occurs every 4 minutes on Indian Roads. Highest road accidents. In the last three years, we have booked around 35 lake cases for various traffic violations such as reckless driving, drunken driving, over sp eeding, driving without license, driving on no-entry roads, Jumping signals and haphazard 10 p. M. And 6 a. M. E because of drunken driving. As you can see in the Table, the Total no. Of Reported road accidents in Bangers has gone down considerably and yet, Vainglorious do not feel safe on the road. During my interactions with a few of you, I got the sense that beyond the minimum required no. Of cases to be booked every month, very few of you take the initiative of booking additional road offenses. We have been facing a lot of criticism from a leading newspaper that claims that 30% of road offenses go unreported. We realized that this is the main reason behind the facts as they hold.And so, to reward those of you who do your Job diligently, (and I am sure most of you already belong to that bracket), we have devised a new policy. We will follow a quarterly appraisal policy wherein each quarter, the 3 officers who book the maximum number of cases will be awarded a Badge of Honor. This badge will signify your commitment to duty, pride and honor towards your department, city and people and education to work. In addition to this, these three people will also be a part of an exclusive Topper's Club which we hope will keep growing every quarter.This club will provide you the opportunity to interact with high achievers from the entire country during the Bi Annual National Meetings and let your family reap benefits for your hard work in the form of fully sponsored family vacations. And finally, at the time of promotions the most hard working of you all will be preferred. The no. Of badges each of you has will stand testimony to this fact. The one with the highest no. Of badges will be promoted as and when the vacancies arise. And now, I'd like you to have a look at this:

Dangers of Authority and Social Pressures Essay - 1298 Words

Hitler and Mussolini were both individuals that used social influences throughout history . Each of these evil villains used authority and social pressure to persuade and manipulate people into performing acts that they wouldn’t normally do . Hitler and Mussolini legitimized their authority through immoral actions and fear and abused their authority. This is important because authority and social pressures are one of the most dangerous combinations there are. The use of these two socially accepted tools have resulted in the deaths of more people, and lead to atrocities such as more genocides than any other social force. . In the 1950s a psychologist Solomon Asch at Rutgers University decided to test group and individuals against in†¦show more content†¦When the engagers were in fronted by their actions they passed the blame to their superiors Solomon Asch`s â€Å"opinions and Social Pressure† studied white college males from a ivy league school. Ash condu cted two experiments, the first was a â€Å"Physiological experiment† which was visual group test the other was a two partner question test. When the participant new they were right they conformed to the majority of the group, forgetting about their own morals and values. Asch found the same results from both test. Asch stated that â€Å"[w]hen consensus comes under the dominance of conformity, the social process is polluted and the individual at the same time surrenders the powers on which his functioning as a feeling and thinking being depends†(357). In â€Å"Perils in Obedience,† Stanley Milgram studied social forces and obedience. Milgram does this by having subjects think they are shocking individuals in a chair for getting wrong answers to questions asked by the subjects. The results showed the participants conformed to the authority of the researchers by going against their own morals and values. Milgram stated that â€Å"[t]hey suspected that only 4 pe rcent would reach 300 volts, and that only a pathological fringe of about one in a thousand would administer the highest shock on the board†(362). He never thought that 60 percent of the subjects would have administered that high of a shock. Milgram connected his results to Nazi Germany and stated that:Show MoreRelatedThe Dangers Of Social Pressure1561 Words   |  7 PagesThe Dangers of Relenting to Social Pressure From early childhood to adulthood, the urge to submit to social pressure is a reality that shapes everyone on a daily basis. The desire to meet societal expectations is a factor that greatly impacts decision making from fashion sense, to choosing friends, and to making the right choices in the work force. Many times, this desire for acceptance repudiates one’s beliefs and innate senses. In â€Å"Opinions and Social Pressure† by Solomon Asch, and â€Å"Perils of Obedience†Read MoreTeen Drinking And Driving921 Words   |  4 Pagesdriving is one of the biggest social issues for teens across the United States. Getting behind the wheel of a vehicle after consuming alcohol is a very dangerous thing no matter what age you are. However, teens do not think about the consequences of drinking and driving until it is already too late. Many things contribute to this growing problem of teen drinking and driving. First, there is a lack of education about drinking and driving in schools today. Next, peer pressure is difficult for many teensRead MoreAs compare to previous two decades, one of the biggest changes we have in 21st century is the1500 Words   |  6 PagesSpecifically, the online Social Networking Websites plays an vital role in the development of the technology era. Social Networking Websites are often called as SNSs. SNSs have changed a lot of things, including our lifestyle, thinking and our perspective on number of things. It made our communication easy, but it is hard to control and monitor the Social networking websites. This uncontrolled nature of Social Networking Websites leads to consequences such as cyber bullying, peer-pressure, mental-health issuesRead MoreDetecting Facial Cues and Body Language747 Words   |  3 Pagesas going up to a vicious person might be an inherently costly mistake than avoiding a person who is actually safe to approach ( Haselton Buss, 2000). A highly adapted system of perception might be more attuned to locating cues that would signify danger, such as the facial intensity in locating hints of anger, in individuals who seem to possess the capability in dealing out more harm as distinguished by their built, carrying armaments and other details. Some might not even present any immediate riskRead MoreQuestions on Emergency Preparation717 Words   |  3 Pagesyou think? I think super storm sandy should act as a warning to the authority on adoption and implementation of crucial measures in relation to the prevention of future occurrences of similar events. The event was a cause of numerous deaths, darkness, and destruction of properties thus leaving the society under enormous pressure economically, socially, and psychologically. The occurrence should be a wake up call for authority and society to enhance their preparedness in order to minimize devastationRead MorePersuasive Essay On Conformity1016 Words   |  5 Pagesourselves for conforming? As a struggling college student, today we are continually attempting to fit in and discover their place and role in society. Drug and alcohol abuse are turning into the responses for us so we do not have to deal with the social expectations of society. 3 out of 4 of high schoolers have reported that school stress is the reason behind it (12 Keys Rehab, 2013). Imagine there were 4 people in a room and 3 of them were alcoholics, that’s a lot, isn’t it? Would you want to liveRead MoreThe Stanford Prison Experiment And Jonestown1450 Words   |  6 Pagessuch as authority pressure, peer pressure, and situational pressure. In looking at articles like ‘The Stanford Prison Experiment’ and â€Å"Jonestown†, the categories above can be confirmed. The articles show how people conform to the circumstances that surround them and provide little or no objection to the situation. The use of a tobacco product is a prime example of a detrimental action that people pa rticipate in due to the pressures placed on them or innuendos that are implied through authority, peersRead MoreHoarding And Its Effects On Children1583 Words   |  7 Pagesâ€Å"it is general agreed that when a person’s collecting affects his or her environment in such a way that causes danger to him or herself or others, intervention is necessary.† Although there is much research on adults with hoarding behaviors, there is limited research on the effects of hoarding among the elderly population. Hoarding behaviors among elderly adults can be seen as a danger to one’s health over time has it can harm their physical health, safety and overall well-being. â€Å"In addition, peopleRead MoreThe Migram Experiment1309 Words   |  5 PagesThe Milgram Experiment has acquired wide popularity and spread among scientists and psychologist who have expressed their doubts concerning its results. The main essence of the experience consisted in checking the way the participant obeyed to authority although they have to do harm to other participants. Hence, the person who controlled the experiment told the subject of the experiment to check memory of another volunteer on the way he/she can remember the pair of words. In case of failure of memorizingRead MoreThe Effects Of Binge Drinking On College Students1139 Words   |  5 Pagesinto five main sections. In my first section I discuss the cognitive development that makes college students more susceptible to excessive binge drinking. In the second section, I discuss the social interactions that promote social drinking among college students. In the third section, I discuss the dangers and life lon g detriment to physical and emotional aspects in life. In the fourth section, I provide possible solutions to help prevent binge drinking among college students. I end my paper with